Silicon Valley Sleuth, an insider's view from Silicon Valley
A blog from vnunet.com



Other blogs
PCW Inter@ctive
Your views, your comments, your say

Security Watchdog
Sniffing out IT security
issues

The test bed
The hottest products, news and gossip from PCW's
Labs.

IT Sneak
IT Sneak Blog rummages in the dustbin of IT events.

Backbytes
An irreverent and offbeat look at the lighter side of technology

InterActive Home
Your complete guide to home entertainment technology

Taking Stock
Gags and Gossip from Accountancy Age.

Gizmodo
The gadgets weblog.



« Microsoft's EU settlement unfriendly to open source | Main | Microsoft cuts Windows reduction »

Microsoft enters the age of mythology

Microsoft enters the age of mythology

Microsoft put on the Linux bashing hat once again, and the company's British platform strategist Nick McGrath is cheerfully jabbing away.

In an interview with vnunet.com he calls the security of Linux "a myth". Not only do just "a fee hundred developers" work on the suite, no-one takes responsibility for the software.

"Who is accountable for the security of the Linux kernel? Does Red Hat, for example, take responsibility? It cannot, as it does not produce the Linux kernel. It produces one distribution of Linux," McGrath said.

So let's do a fun thought experiment.

Does Microsoft take responsibility and even accountability for Windows? Can a bank file charges against the company when it looses billions of dollars due to a security glitch in Microsoft's software? It can't, because of a nasty little thing called software licences, which force users to waive all their rights to being treated as a paying customer.

If my Ford Explorer rolls over when I make a sharp turn, I can sue Ford because they failed to warn me against this – this isn't a fairy tale: Ford in the past has settled such cases and they do warn against it now. But if Microsoft builds an operating system that costs society billions of dollars (or pounds or euros for that matter) because of sloppy programming, Bill Gates laughs all the way to the bank.

Mr. McGrath, if you want to take on Linux, don't start talking about "responsibility". Coming from Microsoft, the R-word doesn't have much credibility.

January 31, 2005 at 04:32 PM | Permalink

Comments

Post a comment






 

Useful links: About | Privacy policy | Terms & conditions | Top of the page
© Incisive Media Ltd. 2008
Incisive Media Limited, Haymarket House, 28-29 Haymarket, London SW1Y 4RX, is a company registered in the United Kingdom with company registration number 04038503