« Shaming more adware funders | Main | Vonage VoIP IPO going down »
Eolas: "No need to change Internet Explorer, just pay us"
Microsoft on 11 April will release a patch that changes Internet Explorer so that the browser no longer violates a patent owned by Eolas. The change will require users to click or press keys before embedded elements on a webpage are activated.
The changes caused Eolas to lash out against Microsoft. They worsen of the users' browser experience, Eolas COO Mark Swords told eWeek. Instead, Microsoft should purchase a license on the dispute technology.
Is Eolas suddenly a consumer advocate? Or is the company really just looking to rake in some more money in addition to the $521m that it was awarded in a 2003 lawsuit?
Microsoft's decision significantly undermines Eolas' position. The software developer has shown that it doesn't need Eolas' technology, sending a signal that it doesn't plan to pay any outrageous sum. In essese, the update has downgraded the technology to the bargain basement: nice to have, but showing notable defects.
We witnessed how outrageous these license fees can get in the Blackberry-NTP case. There a jury awarded about $100m in damages for the patent violation. But Blackerry maker RIM had to pay another $500m to purchase a license on the technology.
The Eolas case just offers additional proof that there is an urgent need for patent reform, and that software patents should be treated differently from traditional patents for instance in the pharmaceutical industry.
I doubt however that this case will do anything to speed up that reform process. Microsoft is itself greatly profiting from the broken patent system, and will likely see this as a single incident. It's hard to be a patent optimist these days.
Photo credit: Ken Duncan
Tags: patent reform, patent, Microsoft, internet explorer, eolas
March 31, 2006 at 08:59 PM | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451b07469e200d8348345b653ef
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Eolas: "No need to change Internet Explorer, just pay us":
Comments
"It's hard to be a patent optimist these days."
Unless you are a lawyer.
Posted-by: Mike | 1 Apr 2006 10:32:07
Spanish
